Freshly prepared subs with vibrant ingredients
🌟 Elwood's Favorite Sub Shop

Stack It High,
Bite Into Bliss

Handcrafted subs piled high with premium meats, melted cheeses, and crisp fresh veggies — baked on soft, toasted hoagie rolls. Your new favorite lunch starts right here.

🥩 Premium Meats
🥬 Fresh Daily
❤️ Made with Love
Scroll to explore
Warm interior of Subtastic Subs restaurant
🏠 Locally Owned & Operated

More Than Just a Sub Shop

Nestled right here in Elwood, Subtastic Subs has been serving up honest, hearty subs that keep folks coming back for more. We started with a simple idea: great food shouldn't be complicated.

Every sandwich is handcrafted right in front of you — we lay out the freshest ingredients, stack them high on a toasted hoagie roll, and give it our personal touch. No shortcuts, no frozen fillers, just real food made with real care.

Whether you're grabbing a quick lunch, feeding the family, or planning catering for your next event, we treat every order like it's for our own table. That's the Subtastic promise.

❤️ Made with Love
🥖 Fresh Bread Daily
🌿 Crisp Veggies Daily
🤝 Community First

What Our Regulars Say

Nothing makes us happier than a satisfied customer. Here's what people are saying about Subtastic Subs!

★★★★★

"Best subs in Elwood, hands down! The Italian Dream is absolutely loaded — I come here at least once a week and it never disappoints."

M
Regular Customer
★★★★★

"Such a friendly crew! They remember my order and always make it perfectly. The chicken parm sub is to die for — so cheesy and delicious."

S
Loyal Fan
★★★★★

"We ordered catering for our office party and everyone was raving about the subs. Fresh, generous portions, and great prices. Will definitely order again!"

J
Event Organizer

Come Say Hi!

We're right here in the heart of Elwood — stop by anytime and we'll have your sub ready in a jiffy.

📍
Address 1600 S A St, Elwood 46036-2011
📞
🕐
Hours Mon – Sat: 10:00 AM – 8:00 PM
Sunday: Closed
📍

Subtastic Subs

1600 S A St
Elwood, IN 46036-2011

Open in Google Maps
Delicious subs ready to be enjoyed

Hungry Yet?

Every sub is made fresh to order. Walk in, call ahead, or stop by — we're ready when you are!

Is this your business?This is my business